The Collins R-390A is arguably the finest tube-era military HF receiver ever built — but it was designed in the early 1950s for AM and CW reception. As amateur and military communications transitioned to single-sideband (SSB), several aftermarket solutions emerged to bring SSB capability to this legendary receiver. This article compares the three principal approaches documented in the R-390A community, drawing on the work of Bob Thomas (VE3TOU), Dr. Dallas Lankford, and Sherwood Engineering.
For step-by-step instructions on copying SSB and fitting the Lankford mod, see the companion R-390A SSB how-to. For how owners have tackled SSB since the 1950s, see SSB and the Collins R-390A: From Military Converters to SDRs.
1. Treetop Circuits SB-390
Type: Commercial external SSB adapter
Production: 2013 – early 2020s (five documented revisions)
Status: Out of production; Treetop Circuits owned by the author since 2026 (see disclosure below)
The SB-390 was the product that most defined Treetop Circuits’ reputation in the boatanchor community. It mounts externally on the receiver’s back terminals, is powered from the receiver itself, and leaves AM operation completely unaffected. The adapter uses a single-balanced product detector architecture with wide dynamic range, paired with a dual-time-constant AGC system designed to resist blocking on impulse noise while providing the fast attack and smooth recovery that makes SSB copy comfortable over long operating sessions.
Pros
- Purpose-built specifically for the R-390 and R-390A receiver
- Mounts externally — no internal modifications required
- AM operation completely unaffected
- Powered from the receiver (no external power supply needed)
- Dual-time-constant AGC with impulse noise resistance for comfortable long-session SSB listening
- Refined through five documented revisions over its production run
- Over 700 units shipped across all Treetop models; widely regarded as the finest commercially available SSB adapter for vintage military HF receivers
Cons
- No longer in production — must be sourced on the used market. Schematics and build notes circulate in the community, but the current owner hasn’t formally released the designs into the public domain
- External mounting adds a box/enclosure to the rear of the receiver
- S-meter behaviour is affected in SSB mode — the meter does not read as accurately as in AM
2. Lankford 2-Diode SSB AGC Modification
Type: DIY internal modification (AGC circuit)
First Published: Hollow State Newsletter #23 (Fall 1989), building on the Cornelius AGC mod in HSN #1 and #10; revisited in #27 and #36
Status: Always available — fully documented in public archives
Lankford’s most famous contribution to the R-390A community, the 2-diode SSB AGC modification adds two small-signal diodes in parallel with resistors in the AGC circuit of the IF deck. The modification is so widely adopted that references to “the Lankford mod” on the R-390 mailing list require no further explanation. Lankford described it in the Hollow State Newsletter (issue 23, Fall 1989), with AGC and BFO refinements in issue 27.
“It is so simple and reversible, and makes such a huge difference in SSB reception, I can’t think of a good reason not to do it.”
— R-390 MAILING LIST CONTRIBUTOR, DESCRIBING THE LANKFORD 2-DIODE SSB AGC MOD
Pros
- Extremely simple — two 1N4148 or 1N914 silicon diodes (Lankford’s earlier 1N270 suggestion was dropped because of its back leakage) and optionally a 47 pF capacitor
- Completely reversible — no parts removed, no holes drilled
- Entirely internal; no external box or enclosure
- Virtually free (a few cents in parts)
- Makes the stock AGC function properly on SSB — operators can listen at full RF gain without riding the gain control
- The most universally adopted R-390A SSB modification in the community
- Published by Lankford in the Hollow State Newsletter (issues 23 and 27)
- Lankford also recommended increasing BFO injection (47 pF across existing 12 pF C535) to prevent audio distortion during SSB reception
Cons
- AGC modification only — does not add a product detector
- SSB audio quality is limited by the receiver’s stock AM envelope detector
- Requires opening the IF deck and soldering (though minimally invasive)
- Requires technical comfort with schematics — Lankford’s documentation is rigorous but demanding
- Does not address the fundamental limitation that the R-390A’s detector was designed for AM, not SSB demodulation
3. Sherwood Engineering SE-3
Type: Commercial outboard synchronous detector / product detector
Status: Limited availability; used market only
The Sherwood SE-3 is a premium outboard product detector and synchronous detector that connects to the receiver’s IF output. It is not designed specifically for the R-390A but works well with it and with many other vintage receivers. Clemens Stubbe Østergaard, a longtime R-390A community member, has described it as something he values as much today as when he first acquired it.
Pros
- Superior SSB audio quality — true high-quality product detector
- Also provides synchronous AM detection, significantly improving AM reception quality
- Works with multiple receivers — a versatile investment, not limited to the R-390A
- No internal modifications to the receiver required
- Highly valued by serious DXers and collectors worldwide
Cons
- Expensive — a premium product with premium pricing
- Requires its own separate power supply
- Adds to the operating footprint (external unit)
- Not R-390A-specific — integration is not as seamless as the purpose-built SB-390
- Very limited availability on the used market
Comparison Table
| Feature | Treetop SB-390 | Lankford 2-Diode Mod | Sherwood SE-3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Commercial external adapter | DIY internal AGC mod | Commercial outboard detector |
| Product Detector | Yes — single-balanced | No — uses existing BFO/detector | Yes — high-quality |
| AGC Improvement | Yes — dual-time-constant | Yes — fixes AGC for SSB | Dependent on receiver AGC |
| Installation | External, on back terminals | Internal — 2 diodes in IF deck | External, to IF output |
| Reversible | Yes — fully external | Yes — no parts removed | Yes — fully external |
| Cost | Moderate | Nearly free | High |
| Availability | Used market only | Always available | Used market only |
| AM Affected? | No | No | No (enhances AM) |
| SSB Audio Quality | Excellent | Limited by stock detector | Superior |
Recommendation
For most R-390A operators, the practical approach is straightforward: install the Lankford 2-diode AGC mod first. It costs virtually nothing, is fully reversible, and is universally recommended as the essential starting point for any R-390A used on SSB. From there, pursue an SB-390 from the used market if you want dedicated product detector capability without compromising the receiver’s internals. The Sherwood SE-3 represents the premium path for operators who demand the best possible audio quality across all modes and who operate multiple vintage receivers.
Step-by-step instructions for the Lankford mod, along with the BFO technique for an unmodified receiver, are in the R-390A SSB how-to.
Other Approaches Over the Years
These three aren’t the only routes. A few others are covered in more depth in SSB and the Collins R-390A: From Military Converters to SDRs:
- Military converters. The TMC CV-591A/URR and the larger Collins CV-157/URR took the R-390A’s 455 kHz IF output and did the sideband detection in a separate rack unit.
- Captain Lee’s product detector (1963). An internal conversion that turns the BFO stage into a product detector by replacing the 6BA6 BFO tube with a 6BE6.
- Solid-state outboard detectors. Designs such as the Vintage Radio Products PD-1 and homebrew MC1496 detectors plug into the IF OUT jack.
- SDRs. A software-defined radio on the IF output, or sharing the antenna, can demodulate SSB itself and adds a panadapter display. See Hermes Lite 2 as an R-390A companion panadapter.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I add SSB reception to a Collins R-390A?
The three principal ways to add SSB to a Collins R-390A are the Treetop Circuits SB-390 external adapter, the Lankford 2-diode SSB AGC modification, and the Sherwood Engineering SE-3 outboard detector. Other routes include military converters such as the TMC CV-591A/URR and Collins CV-157/URR, Captain Lee’s 1963 product detector conversion replacing the 6BA6 BFO tube with a 6BE6, solid-state outboard detectors on the IF OUT jack, and SDRs.
What is the Lankford 2-diode SSB AGC modification for the R-390A?
The Lankford 2-diode mod adds two 1N4148 or 1N914 silicon diodes, in parallel with resistors in the R-390A IF deck AGC circuit, so the stock AGC works properly on SSB and the receiver can be run at full RF gain. It is cheap, fully reversible and first appeared in Hollow State Newsletter #23 (Fall 1989). It does not add a product detector, so SSB audio is still limited by the stock AM envelope detector.
How does the Treetop SB-390 compare with the Sherwood SE-3 on an R-390A?
The Treetop SB-390 is purpose-built for the R-390/R-390A, mounts on the back terminals, runs from receiver power and adds a single-balanced product detector with dual-time-constant AGC, though the S-meter reads less accurately in SSB. The Sherwood SE-3 connects to the IF output, gives superior SSB audio plus synchronous AM, and suits many receivers, but needs its own power supply and is expensive. Both are used-market only; Treetop Circuits has been owned by Mike Peace VK6ADA since 2026.
Which R-390A SSB upgrade should I do first?
For most R-390A operators the recommended first step is the Lankford 2-diode AGC mod, because it costs virtually nothing, is fully reversible and is universally treated as the essential starting point for SSB. After that, a used Treetop SB-390 adds dedicated product detector capability without altering the receiver’s internals. The Sherwood SE-3 is the premium path for operators wanting the best audio across all modes on several vintage receivers.
Sources & Further Reading
- SSB on the Collins R-390A: BFO Technique and the Lankford 2-Diode AGC Mod (VK6ADA)
- SSB and the Collins R-390A: From Military Converters to SDRs (VK6ADA)
- Bob Thomas, VE3TOU — Boatanchor Legends Tribute (VK6ADA)
- Dr. Dallas Lankford — Boatanchor Legends Tribute (VK6ADA)
- Clemens Stubbe Østergaard — Boatanchor Legends Tribute (VK6ADA)
- R-390 Series Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) — r-390a.net
- Hollow State Newsletter Archive (VK6ADA)
- Dallas Lankford Collection of Modifications and Projects — kongsfjord.no
Mike Peace VK6ADA / r-390a.net and foxtango.org Administrator